Okay, everyone has to go to iTunes > Store > Update Genius first so we get the most accurate results.

It's meant to get smarter with what it recommends to you the more it learns, so pick a song at random and tell us what song it recommends.

Okay
A Screw - The Swans

Recommended:
The Modern Lovers
COIL
Magazine
Swans
Cocteau Twins
Skinny Puppy

Not bad at all! How about you?