In my opinion 2 albums stick out like sore thumbs and that is

Arms Way by Islands

and

Dear Science by TV On The Radio

Both fundemently good, but all feel incredibly soulesss as if the music is just there. TV On The Radio is still a strong album but deffinatly isnt as good as everyone is making it out to be (initial buzz) and Islands album is just so mediocre it hurts.

Sebastian Grainer, also! WTF! :( I miss DFA, the EP was good but over the course of an album it just doesnt work!