well the answer i think is both. they havn`t got a bad album really, even suck it... has good moments. but boring they are. i find alex the most charismatic but don`t like his current look. the long hair humbug era looks awful when u see it now. they never really have had a great look. on-stage they need to loosen up a bit. also their guitar riffs are never really allowed to shine. jamie cook needs to play a more key part or just be allowed to let go a bit more. onstage the others don`t really have any stage presence at all. they should take a few notes off blur...